The Truck Driver's Gear Change Hall Of Shame FAQ  |  Browse by artist  |  Browse by title  |  Browse by year  |  Other stuff  

 

Culprit The Beatles REPEAT OFFENDER!
Title Penny Lane
Year 1967
Written by John Lennon and Paul McCartney
Submitted by Dominic

This is apparently a pointless, raw jump up a tone at the end of a song for no good reason. The suspicion that this is just padding to stretch the song out a bit is reinforced by the flute following the vocal melody and the absurd trumpet blasts which seem to say "hey, this is a bit different to the last chorus, honestly!" Yet in a brave defence of Macca's songwriting skills, Dominic Pedler points out in his "Muso's introduction" article that the final chorus does actually end up at the original key of B in which the song starts, thereby coming full circle. I have to say that, even with this realisation, listening to the song in its entirety does little to offset the twang of pain caused by the final shift.

Listen to the MP3Listen!